Patna High Court Case Commentaries

Arbitrary Tender Exclusion May Justify Writ Compensation Where Restoration Would Disrupt Public Work

Date: Nov 3, 2026

Arbitrary Tender Exclusion May Justify Writ Compensation Where Restoration Would Disrupt Public Work Case: The State Of Bihar and Ors v. Kamakshi Minakshi Construction Private Limited and Anr Court:...

Common Intention Cannot Cure Uncertain Identification: Cumulative Evidentiary Defects Require Benefit of Doubt

Date: Oct 16, 2026

Common Intention Cannot Cure Uncertain Identification: Cumulative Evidentiary Defects Require Benefit of Doubt Case: Karpuri Thakur and Anr v. The State Of Bihar Court: Patna High Court Judge:...

Mandatory Pre-Cognizance Hearing Under the BNSS and Quashing of Vexatious Extortion Complaints

Date: Oct 16, 2026

Mandatory Pre-Cognizance Hearing Under the BNSS and Quashing of Vexatious Extortion Complaints Case: RAKESH KUMAR TIWARY v. The State of Bihar Court: Patna High Court Judge: Justice Soni Shrivastava...

Recruitment-Impersonation Dismissal Cannot Rest Solely on an Unproved Handwriting Report

Date: Oct 16, 2026

Recruitment-Impersonation Dismissal Cannot Rest Solely on an Unproved Handwriting Report Case: Rahul Kumar Gautam v. The Punjab National Bank, Through Its General Manager and Ors Court: Patna High...

Restraint During a Shooting Does Not Automatically Establish Common Intention to Attempt Murder

Date: Oct 14, 2026

Restraint During a Shooting Does Not Automatically Establish Common Intention to Attempt Murder Case: Nandu Thakur v. The State Of Bihar Court: Patna High Court | Judge: Justice Chandra Shekhar Jha |...

Covid-19 Ex-Gratia Relief: Hospital Date Discrepancies Alone Cannot Justify Rejection

Date: Oct 13, 2026

Covid-19 Ex-Gratia Relief: Hospital Date Discrepancies Alone Cannot Justify Rejection Case: Shanti Devi v. The State of Bihar Court: Patna High Court Case number: Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No....

Bail Obtained by Misrepresenting a High Court Order Can Be Annulled Without Proof of Subsequent Misconduct

Date: Oct 13, 2026

Bail Obtained by Misrepresenting a High Court Order Can Be Annulled Without Proof of Subsequent Misconduct Case: Chandan Kumar v. The State of Bihar Court: Patna High Court Judge: Sandeep Kumar, J....

Accused-Specific Evidence and Trial Delay Justify Bail in a UAPA Prosecution

Date: Oct 10, 2026

Accused-Specific Evidence and Trial Delay Justify Bail in a UAPA Prosecution Case: Satyam Kumar v. The Union of India through National Investigation Agency, New Delhi Court: Patna High Court Bench:...

Post-Retirement Pension Proceedings: Service of Charges, the Four-Year Bar and Limits on Remand

Date: Oct 10, 2026

Post-Retirement Pension Proceedings: Service of Charges, the Four-Year Bar and Limits on Remand Case: Umesh Kr. Verma v. The State Of Bihar and Ors Court: Patna High Court Judge: Kumar Manish, J....

Written Grounds of Arrest Are Mandatory: A Template Arrest Memo Cannot Sustain Custody

Date: Oct 7, 2026

Written Grounds of Arrest Are Mandatory: A Template Arrest Memo Cannot Sustain Custody Case: Sarfaraz @ Muzaffar Ahmad Wani v. The Union of India through National Investigation Agency Court: Patna...

Mere Registration of an FIR Cannot Justify Cancellation of a PDS Licence

Date: Sep 29, 2026

Mere Registration of an FIR Cannot Justify Cancellation of a PDS Licence Case: Sakindra Roy v. The State of Bihar Court: Patna High Court Coram: Hon’ble Justice Smt. G. Anupama Chakravarthy Date: 22...

Arms Licence Refusal Requires Objective Public-Safety Reasons; An Acquitted Criminal Case Cannot Sustain Rejection

Date: Sep 29, 2026

Arms Licence Refusal Requires Objective Public-Safety Reasons; An Acquitted Criminal Case Cannot Sustain Rejection Case: Sanjay Kumar Yadav v. The State of Bihar Court: Patna High Court Coram:...

Departmental Procedural Lapses Cannot Defeat a Contractor’s Admitted Dues Without Proof of Contractual Default

Date: Sep 28, 2026

Departmental Procedural Lapses Cannot Defeat a Contractor’s Admitted Dues Without Proof of Contractual Default Case: Navin Kumar v. The State Of Bihar and Ors Court: Patna High Court Coram: Hon’ble...

Unsupported Personal Aspersions by Quasi-Judicial Authorities Are Liable to Expungement

Date: Sep 25, 2026

Unsupported Personal Aspersions by Quasi-Judicial Authorities Are Liable to Expungement Case: Dr. Dev Narayan Jha v. The State of Bihar Court: Patna High Court Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Alok Kumar...

Cognizance Orders Must Reflect Application of Judicial Mind—Printed Proforma Summoning Orders Are Unsustainable

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Cognizance Orders Must Reflect Application of Judicial Mind—Printed Proforma Summoning Orders Are Unsustainable 1. Introduction In DEO CHANDRA CHAUDHARY @ DEVENDRA CHAUDHARY v. THE STATE OF BIHAR...

Juvenile Bail Under Section 12 JJ Act Prevails Despite NDPS Commercial Quantity: Gravity Not a Standalone Ground to Refuse Bail

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Juvenile Bail Under Section 12 JJ Act Prevails Despite NDPS Commercial Quantity: Gravity Not a Standalone Ground to Refuse Bail 1. Introduction The Patna High Court, in XX (CICL) v. D.R.I. Patna...

Bihar Prison Remission Must Be Transparent, Reviewable and Non-Discriminatory

Date: Sep 19, 2026

Bihar Prison Remission Must Be Transparent, Reviewable and Non-Discriminatory Case: In view of minutes dt- 17.12.25 of Hon'ble The A.C.J. based on SLP(Crl) No. 529/21 v. The State of Bihar through...

Rule 19 Minor Penalty Proceedings: Disputed Facts Require Fair Disclosure and Proof—Newspaper Reports Are Not Evidence

Date: Sep 2, 2026

Rule 19 Minor Penalty Proceedings: Disputed Facts Require Fair Disclosure and Proof—Newspaper Reports Are Not Evidence Case: Pankaj Kumar v. The State of Bihar Court: Patna High Court Date:...

Religious Processions Are Protected but Not Absolute: Licensing, Public Order, and the “Essential Practice” Limit

Date: Aug 21, 2026

Religious Processions Are Protected but Not Absolute: Licensing, Public Order, and the “Essential Practice” Limit 1. Introduction In Bhadai Chaudhary v. The State of Bihar (Patna High Court,...

Reservation for Mukhiya Elections Is Governed by the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, Not the 1991/2003 Service-Reservation Statute

Date: Aug 15, 2026

Reservation for Mukhiya Elections Is Governed by the Bihar Panchayat Raj Act, Not the 1991/2003 Service-Reservation Statute Case: Md. Isa v. The State of Bihar (Patna High Court, decided on...